Second Admin Can't Format Text?

Here is what I can see when I try to format text using Text Block settings as the first administrator (me): http://s14.postimg.org/nh97ahz2p/Screen_Shot_2015_04_06_at_3_16_19_PM.png

But here is what the second user sees (I set him up as an administrator) when he tries to format text using Text Block settings:http://s9.postimg.org/cqe82hf5b/seconduser.png

Why does the other user not have the same text editing settings as me? (Specifically, changing font size from paragraph to header 1, etc.)